Talk:Appalling TikToks Wiki

From Appalling TikToks Wiki
(Redirected from Talk:Appalling TikToks Wiki)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The rules

Regarding rule 4, the problem is not the mh:meta:Code of Conduct, which pertains to users interacting with other users. The problem is in mh:meta:Content Policy, where poorly or unsubstantiated claims regarding people and groups can result in unwanted attention, potential risk to the platform/other wikis and at its most severe, legal action. Also relevant is this section (quoted verbatum):

"Miraheze does not host wikis with the sole purpose to spread unsubstantiated insult, hate or rumours against a person or group of people

Content on wikis must be fairly balanced, meaningful or substantiated by independent referencing. Wikis which have a clearly identifiable comedic or satire value are exempt from needing to substantiate claims as these provide a meaningful value in terms of relevant content."

This issue stems from the typical reception wiki page regarding a person having few to no sources, having weak, partisan or unrelated sourcing when they do have them and often approaching with a clearly biased and combative tone tone that also does not quite meet a reasonable definition of satire. "Code of Conduct" is only referenced as a misconception, and I take this opportunity to try and correct it here.

While I'm opining on the rules, I'll further note that 5 is contradictory - you cannot tell people to avoid politics, then make an exception that calls for people to bash political or SJW commentary. It is a political and often inflammatory thing to do, though not necessarily a policy violation.

Thank you for considering. --Raidarr (talk) 22:53, 15 November 2021 (UTC)

@Raidarr: I mentioned the thing about confusing CoC and Content Policy on the founder's talk page, but I now see that you already did it. FatBurn0000 (talk) 12:09, 17 November 2021 (UTC)

A page on AndrewIVX?

Once I make 10 edits/become autoconfirmed, is Andrew Zhu/AndrewIVX a TikTok creator I can write a page about? He's mostly a troll who does spread many harmful ideas (but redeemed himself). I'd say he's noticeable enough with his amounts of followers. ChessPiece21 (talk) 17:07, 26 December 2021 (UTC)

Remove closed wikis

I’ve got the wiki list on the home page, and every wiki that has been closed has been put in bold so it can be removed from the list: Loathsome Characters Wiki
, Incredible Characters Wiki, Classic media reception wikis, Garbage Roblox Games Wiki, 
Perfect Roblox Games Wiki
, Perfection Roblox Games Wiki
Horrid Video Game Mods Wiki
, Horrible Friday Night Funkin' Mods Wiki
Spectacular Gameplay Wiki, 
Crappy Software Wiki
, Disastrous TV Networks & Channels Wiki
, Horrible Music Wiki
, Excellent Music Wiki, 
Horrible Companies Wiki, 
Fabulous Celebrities Wiki, Rotten Websites Wiki, 
Users Wiki, 
Amazing YouTubers Wiki, 
Trashy Vyond Videos Wiki,
Decent Vyond Videos Wiki, 
Astonishing Scratchers Wiki
, Wonderful DeviantArt Wiki
, Tiresome Wikis Wiki, Ugly Logos Wikia, 
Unwatchable Sports Wiki, Cancelled Games Wiki, 
Cancelled Movies Wiki, 
Cancelled TV and Web Shows Wiki,
Closed Websites Wiki, Rumoured Movies Wiki, 
Real Life Villains Wiki Thanks for your consideration in looking at this! --SquirtSquirtle (talk) 14:47, 23 July 2023 (UTC)